OpenAI Dots vs OpenClaw: An Always-On Agent Inside ChatGPT vs an Open-Source Agent You Host Yourself

Urteile nach Aufgabe

Trying a persistent agent without installing anythingOpenAI Dots gewinnt

Dots runs in ChatGPT on its own cloud computer and you message or call it on desktop, web and mobile, while OpenClaw is installed through a script or npm.

Dots is listed for Pro and Business Premium in eligible markets, and the pricing page shows Pro from $100 a month.

Keeping agent state on your own hardwareOpenClaw gewinnt

The README says state, memory and credentials live on your hardware; each dot works on OpenAI's cloud computer.

OpenClaw's docs say it is not a hostile multi-tenant boundary, so do not share one gateway among users who distrust each other.

Choosing the model or running a local oneOpenClaw gewinnt

OpenClaw's providers page lists hosted providers and local runtimes such as Ollama, vLLM and llama.cpp; the Dots page names GPT-6 Astra and no alternative.

You supply and pay for the model access, and we read no OpenClaw cost figure.

Chatting with the agent from Telegram, Discord, Signal or iMessageOpenClaw gewinnt

openclaw.ai lists 29 channels that include all four.

Dots lists Slack and Teams, with texting coming soon, plus calling inside ChatGPT.

Software costOpenClaw gewinnt

OpenClaw states no subscription, no hosted tier and no token, while Dots is included in Pro (listed "From $100 / month") and Business Premium (price not shown on the pricing page we read).

OpenClaw needs a model provider and your own machine; the cost of those is not on the pages we read, and we have not tested either product.

Connecting a large catalogue of appsOpenAI Dots gewinnt

OpenAI says dots can connect to over 4,000 apps through its plugin ecosystem.

The count is OpenAI's figure; OpenClaw's pages we read give no app count, and Unit 42's research describes malicious skills on ClawHub.

A vendor path for enterprise governanceOpenAI Dots gewinnt

OpenAI offers an Enterprise beta and says it is working on Agent 365 integration.

The Enterprise rollout is a beta and the specialist dots are a preview; OpenClaw lists no enterprise edition on the pages we read.

Funktionsvergleich

KI-nativ
OpenAI Dots:KI-nativ
OpenClaw:KI-nativ
What it is
OpenAI Dots:OpenAI's launch page calls dots "remarkably capable, always-on agents built to handle everything" in ChatGPT, "Powered by GPT-6 Astra".
OpenClaw:The OpenClaw repository describes an open-source AI assistant that runs on personal computers and is reached through chat apps; the site headline is "The AI that really does things." openclaw.ai says "OpenAI is a donor and Peter Steinberger works there; OpenClaw is not an OpenAI product."

A hosted agent that comes with a ChatGPT plan against software you run yourself. OpenAI is a donor to OpenClaw per its own site, and the pages we read describe no Dots integration in either direction

Price
OpenAI Dots:"Your first dot is included in your Pro or Business Premium plan at no extra cost." The ChatGPT pricing page lists Pro at "From $100 / month" with "Dot, your always-on agent"; the page we read shows no Business Premium price. The launch page says "In the future, you'll be able to add more dots" and gives no price for them on the pages we read.
OpenClaw:"No subscription. No hosted tier. No token." and "There is no enterprise edition and no paid version." The model is bring-your-own, so provider charges are separate and we read no figure for them.

OpenClaw software costs $0. Dots is included in ChatGPT Pro, listed at "From $100 / month", and in Business Premium, whose price the pricing page we read does not show. OpenClaw's all-in cost depends on the model provider you choose, and no figure for it appears on the pages we read

Where it runs
OpenAI Dots:"Each dot works on its own cloud computer, while your computer and its contents stay separate unless you choose to connect it."
OpenClaw:"State lives on your machine, not a vendor cloud" (Mac, Windows or Linux); the README says "State, memory, and credentials live on your hardware."

OpenClaw for keeping state on hardware you control; Dots for an agent that works on its own computer apart from yours

Availability
OpenAI Dots:"Dots are rolling out today in ChatGPT to Pro and Business Premium users in eligible markets." Enterprise users, including Edu and Healthcare, "can try the beta when their workspace admin enables it."
OpenClaw:Installs through a script or npm; the README lists Node 24.22.1+ or 26.12.1+ (Node 26 recommended) and says the installer provisions a Node.js runtime.

Dots is limited to listed plans in eligible markets; the OpenClaw pages we read state no market or plan limit, but you do the install

How you reach it
OpenAI Dots:"You can message or call dots in ChatGPT on desktop, web, and mobile." Also "message your dot in Slack and Teams, with texting coming soon."
OpenClaw:openclaw.ai counts 29 channels including WhatsApp, Telegram, Discord, Slack, iMessage and Signal; the README also names Teams.

OpenClaw lists 29 channels on openclaw.ai. Dots lists messaging and calling in ChatGPT plus Slack and Teams, with texting coming soon

Tools and apps
OpenAI Dots:"Through our ecosystem of plugins, they can readily connect to over 4,000 apps." The page also describes app tools restricted to read-only that "can't send messages, change app content, or control your browser or computer." Each dot has "their own browser".
OpenClaw:"Browses the web, fills forms, reads and writes files, runs shell commands"; the site lists a Gmail Inbox card ("Read, draft, and manage email"); docs navigation lists a ClawHub plugin marketplace. The pages we read give no app count.

Dots states over 4,000 connectable apps, which is OpenAI's own figure. OpenClaw's pages we read give no app count, and its file and shell access runs on your own machine

Background work
OpenAI Dots:Dots "can work towards your goals 24/7"; an "Activity View" for monitoring progress.
OpenClaw:"OpenClaw runs work in the background through native runtimes, scheduled jobs, event hooks, and standing instructions"; the scheduler "supports one-shot reminders, recurring intervals and cron expressions, and inbound webhook triggers."

Both list background work. OpenClaw documents its scheduling mechanisms; the Dots page describes goal-driven 24/7 work without a scheduler description in the text we read

Safety controls
OpenAI Dots:"auto-review to check actions that could affect your accounts"; saved passwords used "without exposing them to the model"; "Custom Rules"; "Activity View".
OpenClaw:On a regular host install the gateway binds to loopback; most chat channels answer unknown DM senders with a pairing code; group access is allowlisted; `openclaw security audit` checks for drift. The README says tools run on the host for the main session unless sandboxing is configured. The docs state OpenClaw "is not a hostile multi-tenant security boundary for mutually adversarial users sharing one agent or gateway." Unit 42's analysis (February to May 2026) reports "persistent and evasive malicious skills on ClawHub" and says "We identified five unblocked skills."; it warns that installation "results in complete control over the agent's identity" and says "OpenClaw banned the accounts mentioned and deleted all of the skills."

Both sets of controls are self-described and neither was independently audited in the pages we read. With OpenClaw you own the configuration and the skill vetting; with Dots OpenAI describes the controls

Models
OpenAI Dots:GPT-6 Astra. The launch page we read describes no choice of model.
OpenClaw:openclaw.ai says it works with Claude and GPT models; the providers page lists Anthropic (API + Claude CLI), OpenAI (API + Codex), Google (Gemini), Amazon Bedrock, and local runtimes llama.cpp, LM Studio, Ollama, vLLM and SGLang.

OpenClaw for choosing a provider or running a local model

Enterprise route
OpenAI Dots:Enterprise beta enabled by a workspace admin; OpenAI says it is "working with Microsoft to integrate specialist dots with their enterprise governance and security controls in Agent 365."
OpenClaw:"There is no enterprise edition and no paid version."

Dots has a vendor enterprise path, in beta. OpenClaw offers none on the pages we read

Immer noch unentschieden zwischen diesen beiden?

Die Wahl ist der leichte Teil. Die Arbeit besteht darin, es in Ihrem Unternehmen zum Laufen zu bringen, mit Ihren Daten und Ihrem Team. Wir machen beides.

Das Gespräch läuft auf Gnosari, einem der Tools in diesem Verzeichnis. Ein echtes Gespräch, kein Verkaufsskript.