Tally vs Fillout: Two Ways to Give the Free Tier Away

Verdicts by Task

The cheapest possible capable formTally wins

An unlimited free plan means the cost never becomes a question, however the traffic turns out.

Fillout's 1,000 free responses a month is enough that most teams never notice the difference.

Responses that must land in Airtable or NotionFillout wins

Writing structured rows straight into an existing database is what Fillout is built around, and it saves the automation you would otherwise write.

If a simple webhook into your own system is enough, this advantage disappears.

A form with pricing logic or quote calculationsFillout wins

Calculations and conditional pricing are native here rather than something to work around.

Complex quoting usually outgrows form builders entirely within a year.

A long text-heavy application formTally wins

Writing the form as a document keeps the copy and the questions in one place, which is exactly what long applications need.

Long applications abandon heavily regardless of the builder, which is a content problem, not a tooling one.

Growing past the free planFillout wins

The step up is $15 a month rather than $24, and buys a clearly stated response increase.

On Tally you may never need to take that step at all.

Feature Comparison

AI-native
Tally:Hybrid
Fillout:AI-Powered
Free plan allowance
Tally:Unlimited submissions within fair use
Fillout:1,000 responses a month

Tally on paper; Fillout's 1,000 clears most real sites anyway.

Entry paid tier
Tally:Pro at $24 a month
Fillout:Starter at $15 a month, 2,000 responses

Fillout is cheaper to start paying for.

Top tier
Tally:Business at $74 a month
Fillout:Business at $75 a month, unlimited responses

Line ball. Decide on features, not the last dollar.

Feature depth
Tally:Deliberately focused: fields, logic, payments
Fillout:Broader: calculations, scheduling, payments, deep integrations

Fillout, if you need any of the extra surface.

Database write-back
Tally:Integrations, but not a core selling point
Fillout:First-class into Airtable, Notion and similar

Fillout, comfortably, and this is the real differentiator.

Authoring feel
Tally:Write a document and fields appear inline
Fillout:A conventional, capable builder

Tally, for anyone who thinks in prose rather than in fields.

Adaptive questioning
Tally:None
Fillout:None

Neither. Both are deterministic forms with an AI assist during authoring.